GARNET HEALTH MEDICAL CENTER
707 EAST MAIN STREET · MIDDLETOWN, NY · 10940 · Acute Care Hospitals
vs. the regional median (the other ~300 NY/NJ/CT hospitals publishing the same code). How is this computed?
High-confidence score: 10% trimmed mean across 52 of 57 target procedures, commercial payers, 5x outlier cap. Based on 52 of 57 high-confidence target procedures. A broader all-codes view (every commercial billing code this hospital publishes, 18,926 codes) puts the score at 1.22x.
GARNET HEALTH MEDICAL CENTER bills above peers — about 1.47x the regional median. Within departments, Inpatient prices are notably high (2.65x, 2,050 codes). The price spread is moderate (B grade), with some procedures priced unexpectedly high.
A nearby hospital 12.51 mi away is ~34% cheaper overall.
ST ANTHONY COMMUNITY HOSPITAL has an overall price level of 0.97x vs. this hospital's 1.47x, with 1,026 procedures in common.
why?
Moderate price spread (IQR ratio 2.3x) with some outliers (13% above 3x)How A/B/C is determined: A = narrow price spread (IQR < 2.0×) with <5% of codes priced more than 3× the regional median. B = moderate (IQR 2.0–3.0× OR 5–20% above 3×). C = wider than that.
Cost by department
Each ratio compares this hospital's prices in that department to the median across NY/NJ/CT hospitals for the same department.
| Department | Ratio | Codes | % above median |
|---|---|---|---|
| Other | 1.57x | 6,734 | 80% |
| Surgery | 1.14x | 6,059 | 63% |
| Inpatient | 2.65x | 2,050 | 86% |
| Lab | 0.95x | 1,691 | 28% |
| Drugs/Pharmacy | 0.99x | 1,301 | 45% |
| Imaging | 1.33x | 722 | 91% |
| Cardiac | 1.50x | 235 | 76% |
| Emergency/Eval | 2.00x | 220 | 91% |
| Therapy | 1.25x | 82 | 79% |
Hospital info
- Type: Acute Care Hospitals
- Ownership: Voluntary non-profit - Private
- Beds: 329
- Annual discharges: 18,905
- CMS overall quality star rating: 3/5
Methodology & sources
Prices extracted from this hospital's CMS-mandated machine-readable transparency file (45 CFR 180). Headline statistic: 10% trimmed mean across 52 of 57 target procedures, commercial payers, 5x outlier cap. Validated against RAND Hospital Price Transparency Study v5.1 employer claims data at Spearman ρ = 0.73 (n = 105 hospitals).
Download the original transparency file from GARNET HEALTH MEDICAL CENTER.